From Edutopia, Social Media-Adopt or Face Irrelevancy,
I read the statement, “Teachers must start teaching in the year we live.” While that is true, most social media remains
unreachable by teachers in my system.
Facebook,Twitter, Youtube, and many others have access blocked from our
classrooms. When I asked to have
specific youtube videos unblocked the request was denied. I was told that to unblock one would require
unblocking all of the youtube website and some of the material was considered
inappropriate.
How will students be
taught what is appropriate to post and what is not, if not taught in
school? Some students come from homes where
their internet usage is closely monitored and others are given free rein on
their internet usage. Are students ever
taught facebook or twitter etiquette or do they stumble along until a mistake
is made? In New York Times Magazine,
February 12, 2015, Jon Ronson wrote the article “How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up
Justine Sacco’s Life.” It told the story
of how one young lady’s tweeted joke she thought was funny nearly ruined her
life. She lost her job, received
threats, and was virtually ruined.
Social media is so perfectly designed to manipulate our
desire for approval (Ronson). Many of
our students are seeking approval of their teachers, but more so from their
peers. I know of a student who made a comment on facebook
concerning bringing a gun to school. This
post was seen by a teacher, reported, and the student was expelled. He said it was just a joke and he would have
never committed such an act. This is
where I think it is important that these young people are taught what is
appropriate and what will land them in a lot of trouble. Many of these kids make statements on
facebook as if they were carrying on a face to face conversation. They do not seem to realize the connotation
of their words can come across very different when read on a screen than when
spoken. Do I think the teacher who
reported the incident over reacted?
Absolutely not! Any mention of
bringing a gun to school should be handled with urgent attention. Do I believe
this young man would have brought a gun to school? No. I
know him. He is not that type of
person. In light of the terrible tragedies
that have occurred in schools across this nation, no statements like these can
go unnoticed. What I wish could have
occurred was some instruction on what should and should not be stated on
facebook. Also, students need to know
once something is posted it is always out there for someone’s eyes.
In the readings for this
assignment, I read about Ashlely Johnston and Jack Parrish at the Trinity
School in Atlanta who taught their students how to blog using paper and pencil
before allowing them to blog on the internet.
They had the opportunity to monitor what the students were writing and
give guidance when needed before the students moved on to internet blogging. I think this type of instruction would be
very beneficial before venturing onto social networking.
I had the opportunity to
talk with several media specialists and teachers in the past few days
concerning this topic. They all had a
common concern of being able to monitor what the students were doing if using
social networking at school. All I spoke
to said they would be very uncomfortable using social networking in their
classrooms.
I myself am trying to use social media to help promote my library, but am running into the problem you have mentioned. I am having to wait till off school campus to create my social media posts. This is the best way to reach my students and get their attention. They spend most of their day on facebook, snapchat, Instagram, and twitter. Without these outlets I would miss out on reaching half of mystudent population. Since I work in a setting with grades 7 and 8th, and we have a BYOD policy, my kids are using their phones at school. This brings me to the other problem you mentioned, there is absolutely 0 digital citizenship classes being taught. I have brought this problem up to my principal and asked to be able to start digital citizenship classes next year and to make them a requirement. HE was onboard with this but I feel like its a little too late for many of our students. This is something they should be being taught at an early age and I feel we are failing them in this endeavor.
ReplyDeleteThis whole topic is very sensitive in all school systems and one that requires attention. As a sensitive subject, I recognize the challenge facing administrators; however, there is mutual accountability between parents, students and the school to ensure our students are engaged and discussions held to ensure they're aware of the proper use of technology. In many instances, over the past few years, school systems have loosened their BYOD protocols and have allowed students to use them during the school day, as evidenced in my son's high school in Alabama. Of course there are rules, but students are also informed and taught the pros and cons of improper use of technology and the consequences that may be assessed as a result of their misuse of this privilege. Adriane's assessment of teaching these skills at an early age is parallel to teaching student's a foreign language at an early age - they'll absorb it like a sponge. In order to ensure students know the potential perils of social media, we need to teach them - if the resources are in the school system, we should provide the appropriate training as well. It's a no-brainer!
ReplyDeleteSocial media is also blocked at the school where I teach. We did have access to the site My Big Campus and students could interact with each other and the teachers. They changed it this year and are going to another site- CANVAS. I do not know enough about it yet. The students are also given email addresses that can be used to connect to other students and teachers. I agree that students need to be taught how to properly use the social media before it can be introduced to them. Especially the older students that need to know it is not the same as texting. You cannot say just anything you want. They need to keep the sole purpose in mind.
ReplyDeleteMary Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI must say that the quote you included was a very powerful statement to make regarding teachers “teaching in the year we live in.” I actually get it. Although, I agree with the statement, I also agree with your thoughts as well. It is easy to say “teach in the year we live”, but how can one do that if one is limited in resources. I am actually surprised that your district does not allow for YouTube videos to be used as teaching tools. There are so many educational videos available. I think that my district lacks in many areas in terms of technology. I know there is a plethora of technology resources that we miss out on, but YouTube is not one of them. Our technology department installed software which allow for certain aspects of some of the sites to be utilized, such as YouTube. YouTube for Schools is an excellent recourse and investment for your district to consider. My district has gone “Google” throughout. I know that there is a setup option available to app administrators in order to restrict YouTube content on a managed network. I tried to include a screenshot of how this can be accomplished, but it did not show up. Try researching it yourself. Maybe your district will consider making this resource available to teachers.
Additionally, the fact that students sometimes do not use common sense when posting on social media is a huge problem. The example you provided regarding the teacher who saw the post by a student commenting on bringing a gun to school is very similar to something which occurred in my district. A junior attending one of the high schools texted a friend about his plan to do harm to the school during the last week of his senior year (2017). It was shared with school officials, and the boy was arrested and later expelled from school. My daughter was one of his classmates. She stated to me that if people really knew the type of person that he was then they would know he would never do anything like that. I had to explain to her that it did not matter. I continued by telling her that incidents like this cannot be taken lightly. It should be considered a lesson learned. I agree with you, students need to be educated regarding the appropriate usage of social media. If not done so at home where is should be taught first, then why not at school?