John Briscoe
February 2, 2016
Wikis
I really like the idea of having a Wiki or multiple Wikis in
the Media Center, but like a lot of things, it takes the perfect amount of
organization, the right amount of encouragement to use them, and enough time
for students and teachers to practice with them to make them feel comfortable
using them.
Calming the nerves of
a teacher…
One of the drawbacks to using a Wiki in a K-12 setting is
the necessity of something a lot of teachers don’t have…time. Every time I come
up with a good example of when creating a Wiki would be good to use in the
classroom, the biggest stumbling block is the immense amount of classroom time
it would take to teach the class how to use the Wiki. As a teacher, do I want
to go to the computer lab or media center multiple times in a week? That’s fine
for certain classes, but what if I have an End-of-Course-Test for that class?
Advanced Placement students would be excellent and creative in developing a
Wiki, but do I want to take that time away from preparing for an AP test that
could give them college credits and save them money down the road? The answer
you give to these skeptical teachers is that you will help them be overly
prepared for giving the projects. As a media specialist, you have to have an
example of something ready. For an AP class, you could have them discuss
whatever book they are reading for class. For the EOCT class, you may not make
it a Teacher-to-Student Wiki. You may encourage teachers to create a Wiki that
allows them to put information and resources valuable for reviewing for their
specific EOCT.
Bottom Line: Cater the Wikis to what teachers and
students need. Don’t just create a Wiki to say you have a Wiki. Create one that
serves a very direct purpose. If you have a Media Center Wiki with 50 different
aspects to it, is it really something that students and teachers are going to
use and benefit from? Wikis need to have a clear objective. For example, my
media specialist does not have a Wiki, but if she did, she says that she would
love to have a specialized Wiki for students to write book reviews, suggest
books to other students, and request books to be purchased for the media
center.
Time in the day…
After talking to a few media specialists, Wikis seem to be
something media specialists would love to have as a regular part of their media
center, but they all seemed to have other things that were more important to
them right now. The media specialist at my school has around 30 kids in her
media center every period working through online education classes. Another
media specialist I talked to is in her first year at the school, and she
directed me to other people because she said it wasn’t high on her priority
list this year. Those people said that they were a little timid to let students
post to official school sites because the county made it very clear that they
didn’t want inappropriate stuff on the sites. Finally, I attempted to contact
the media specialist from Apalachee High School, the school that was given as
an example. I was excited to ask several questions to the media specialist, but
there is a new media specialist there now, and he simply said that the Wiki was
something the old regime did.
Bottom Line: You’re going to make time for what you
see as most important. If you feel like your school’s media center is going to
benefit from having a Wiki, make the time. If teachers need a place to share
ideas and resources, make the time. If students are looking for a place to
share thoughts and ideas, or they are looking for creative ways to do projects,
make the time. If you are creating one just to say you have one, don’t waste
your time.
Collecting Dust…
I can see where Wikis can be seen as “storage cabinets.” Apalachee
High School got a new media specialist a few years ago, and all of the
information and resources have not been updated since the change in personnel.
In order to keep a Media Center’s Wiki an active space for collaboration, it
needs to have information that is needed or can be used in the near future. You
could put someone in charge of one aspect of the Wiki while another person
works on another. You don’t have to update it regularly, but students might be
more apt to peruse the Wiki if your most recent post is closer to 2016 rather
than 2006! For a Wiki that connects the media center with teachers, I think the
most important information to have posted is about curriculum. With curriculums
that are ever-evolving, teachers need to stay up-to-date on all of the
information regarding standards, frameworks, study guides, and other resources.
Having teachers collaborate within a school or district on a Wiki would be a
great way to get traffic!
Bottom Line:
Don’t take on the burden by yourself. Get a team together that is
willing to advocate for and keep the Wiki active. If you’re the only one
willing to post resources for teachers, the Wiki will be collecting dust in the
future.
After reading the articles and talking to four different
media specialists, I’ve come to the conclusion that media specialists see
collaboration as one of the most important aspects of their job (big surprise,
right?). I also feel like the newest, coolest way to collaborate is through
Google, and through a very broad definition of ‘Wiki’, Google can be classified
as a Wiki. Every one of the media specialists I corresponded with seemed
hesitant about creating and maintaining a Wiki, but they all loved the fact
that their students could log into Google and share things. They all loved that
their teachers could upload and share resources through Google Docs. One of the
biggest goals I have as I venture to be a media specialist is collaborating
frequently with teachers and students, and whichever way my students and
teachers respond to best, that’s the route I plan on taking.
Wiki's are new to me, but the Wiki that was created at the beginning of the Semester for the Media Specialist Courses was very helpful. In reading about Wiki's, I didn't realize that Wiki's were meant to be an interactive site. Being that I teach Kindergarten, I don't feel like Wiki's would benefit my students in an interactive way, but I do see a use that Wiki's could provide for the teachers and parents. According to the article 7 Things You Should Know About Wikis (https://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ELI7004.pdf) , Wikis offer a powerful yet flexible collaborative communication tool for developing content-specific Web sites and because wikis grow and evolve as a direct result of people adding material to the site, they can address a variety of pedagogical needs. If I were to create a Wiki right now, as the Grade Level Chair, I would set one up as a direct connect between my team and the parents of Kindergarten. The site could provide grade level projects, helpful websites, curriculum guides, homework ideas, etc.. I feel like this could be a place where parents could voice their concerns about assignments or curriculum and the Kindergarten team could collaborate in providing information to share through the Wiki. As an aspiring Media Specialist, a great use of a Wiki could be used for a School Book Club that would be available to all grade levels. The Wiki would provide the monthly themes, would provide book suggestions for each level and provide to a culminating task for each level to complete. I would utilize parents, teachers, and Book Club members to help guide the themes and projects. Also, to address the time factor, I love the idea of delegating the contributions to any Wiki and making it truly a team effort. Time or the lack thereof is and ever will be any teacher or Media Specialist issue. I very much agree with you when you expressed how you make time for the things that are important. With anything you want to attempt or implement, you have to be invested in creating something useful and meaningful. If not, you are doing nothing but wasting the one thing that is the most valuable to any educator...time. I'm coming to realize that using a Wiki could be a very useful tool if and only if it is used to its highest potential.
ReplyDeleteJohn, I enjoyed reading your thoughts on wikis. To be perfectly honest, I had never heard the term wiki until last semester when I worked with a group to create a Pathfinder on Wiki Spaces. It was quite an undertaking. As you mentioned, time is a huge factor when developing a wiki. Time has to be found to create the wiki and then time is needed to keep the information current. At my school no one is using a wiki because no one knows what it is, except for the digital resource coach. This means that time must also be found to work with teachers to help them learn about wikis- what they are, how to create one, and how it can be used to enhance the curriculum.
ReplyDeleteYou also mentioned collaboration. Collaboration is also critical for developing a wiki. Trying to create one on your own might tend to be overwhelming, especially if it is your first one. Several websites I visited which offered tips for building a wiki, suggested that teachers at work together to build a wiki for the school. This could be used to showcase various events at the school. After working as a group, individuals may feel more comfortable venturing out on their own to create a wiki.
None of the media specialists in my district have created a wiki, including myself. With a little pushing perhaps I can convince them that a wiki for the media center would be a worthwhile project for the next school year.
John, I greatly enjoyed getting to read your thoughts regarding wikis. I got many of the same responses from the media specialists I spoke to about using wikis in schools. For example, the first media specialist I spoke to explained that her main concern was the free editing power that is given to students. She suggested that in order to monitor student posting a wiki can be set up so that posts require the teacher’s approval in order to be viewed by the public. However, this also away the instant communication that is distinctive to wikis. Another media specialist I spoke to explained that she has had more luck with using wikis for professional development instead of student projects. This way the collaborators can freely edit the wiki without the media specialist having to be too concerned with inappropriate posts. Having an interactive wiki for professional development can also allow teachers to learn about new technology at their own pace. I absolutely agree with your suggestion to make a wiki for a distinct purpose as opposed to making one just to have one. By having a goal or use in mind for your wiki you can tailor it to fit the needs of the students or teachers. Also, you will be much happier in the long run when you see your work being used instead of “collecting dust”. Finally, I loved the idea of creating a media center wiki that can be used by students to review books, suggest books for purchase, and recommend books for fellow book lovers.
ReplyDeleteJohn, I love your post - you did an excellent job of conveying your thoughts in a clear manner to the point that I found myself frequently nodding my head. As the K-5 Tech Lab teacher, I started creating wikis about 8 years ago - but in every instance my wikis have been created for teacher use, not student. They are used as collaborative tools, but they are information depositories. The one most frequently "updated" is the one to which we all post our weekly lesson plans and any supporting digital files. Since wikis are an interface with which I am familiar, and they are ad-free for K12 education use, I have also used them for my own teaching depository as well, not collaborative at all! But couldn’t agree more about your statement “don’t just create a wiki to say you have a wiki.” Especially if collaboration is the intent. While wikis are somewhat easy to edit, there is a fairly steep learning curve, at least in wikispaces.com, for any level of detailed formatting. I discovered when creating a group project pathfinder in another of Dr. Cooper’s classes that trying to do anything beyond creating straightforward pages made it difficult for my wiki-inexperienced teammates to follow. Therefore, a wiki that isn’t of great interest to its stakeholders would quickly end up being one of those last updated in 2006! That was one of my “nods” in your comments – one of the first things I do when looking at any wiki and check to see when it was last updated!
ReplyDeleteWith all the options out there now, I really see no value in using a wiki for a Media Center’s main website. The few people that might be involved in updating such a site could just as easily add information to a standard, more user-friendly (and more viewer friendly!). I am intrigued by the idea of using a wiki to showcase student book reviews, trailers, recommendations and wish list. However, I suspect that if I chose to use a wiki, I would end up having students send such information to me to put on the wiki instead of having them post directly. Maybe at the high school level, but the idea of such free posting is a bit unnerving to me, even with the existence of a wiki charter such as that one on the un-used AHS media center wiki (I checked through their current school website and found only a blurb about the media center so it is unfortunate that the wiki has gone by the wayside…).
Wrapping up with my own experience with teacher collaboration using wikis, I did fail in my efforts to get our professional development wiki off the ground. However, just this fall, I’ve added 2 new collaboration tools to our faculties “to do” list, both in Google Sheets: 1) a record of professional development; and 2) a record of technology integration activities in the classroom. Both of these are working well. Recently, I made a teacher error with 5th graders using Google Classroom to introduce Google Slides. Instead of giving each student their own copy, I had them all collaborating in the same file. Many interesting ideas have come out of that mistake and I can see doing some great things with students in the media center along the same vein.
Wiki response—Amelia Couch
ReplyDeleteLast semester I was led kicking and screaming to wikis. I was absolutely convinced I would never learn how to use a wiki. BUT, it was a requirement for Dr. Cooper’s class, so I had to give it a try. WOW!! It was difficult to learn for someone who is as technologically challenged as I, but it was a real eye -opener. It was a team assignment on constructing and using a Pathfinder. The work on our subject was divided among the team members. Somewhere, during the construction of this wiki, it finally dawned on me this would be a great way for collaboration among the grade level teachers in my system. We are a small system, made up of small schools. Until moving to the Library Media Specialist position, I was the sixth grade reading teacher at my school. There was no other 6th grade reading teacher at my school to collaborate with. If I wanted to consult another teacher about the standards, the curriculum, or teaching ideas, it was done through emails and phone calls. If I had known how to use a wiki my life as a classroom teacher would have been made easier. There are 3 other 6th grade reading teachers in my system, who like me, are the only sixth graded reading teacher in their schools. We could have designed lessons and collaborated with each other using a wiki that would have really been beneficial to us all.
I agree with John that wikis take time, and that is something most of us in education are lacking, TIME. While creating a wiki can be time heavy in the beginning, it can be a time saver later on. Things can easily be added to or taken from the original wiki. As a new idea or instruction design comes along, it can be added onto the wiki. If something proves to be unbeneficial to our students it can be removed. Think of a wiki as a fluid instrument that can be tweaked to meet the needs of the current group of students. If beginning with a wiki strictly for collaboration the ideas and materials developed there can then be transferred to a wiki for the students to use. I would recommend keeping the two separate. There will be at times things you want only your colleagues to see and at other times things you want to share with students. As I said earlier, I am technologically challenged, but I love using a wiki. I think, if you will give it a try, you will like wikis, too.
John, I agree with your comment about catering the wiki to benefit your needs and not just creating one just to say that you have one. In my opinion, teachers should be trained thoroughly (not just one meeting) so that they can be confident and collaborate to create wikis that can be used to benefit the students. If teachers are trained adequately, then it would be much easier to collaborate. I only know of a couple of teachers at my school that I could work with to make a wiki because most the teachers don’t know how or what a wiki is (including my media specialist). I have only tried once and can’t say that I am comfortable myself. I also agree that time is a factor and that everyone is so busy. However, you’re right in saying that if it is important, then it will be a priority.
ReplyDeleteI must give you credit on how you laid out this post. Very insightful! As a teacher, I always have to think in terms of my classroom and how I can implement technology. After reading a few of the supplemental materials, I thought long and hard about how I can use wikis. Then I read your post and it gave me some perspective.
ReplyDeleteThe use of wiki, although a great tool to use, you are right—it would take a lot of time to implement into my classes. I teach middle school and out of the four classes I teach, there is only one to which I believe the students can handle the use of wikis—my gifted and honors group. The reason for this is accessibility. These students come with the necessary equipment in order to take the time to plan lessons where wikis are used.
The district I teach in has a mix socio-economic population. The students who are serviced at my school are often times on the opposite ends of the economic scale. One end of the scale is students who are on or below the poverty line while the other end are the students who are upper-middle class. Because of this, the overwhelming majority of my students do not have the technology available to them at home to participate in a BYOD classroom where the use of wikis will be useful. The ones that do are mostly in the one gifted and honors class that I have. Like you stated, I can’t take my students to the few computer labs we have at my school every day. It really can be frustrating situation because I want them to experience these new technologies such as wiki, like my other more fortunate students.
Thank you for taking the time to discuss the use of wikis with a few media specialists. The feedback that they gave you was quite interesting to say the least. It seems that many are aware, but they are so use to using whatever tools they are used to using or have mastered that learning something new was not a priority. Maybe it should be, but I do understand change is hard. I hope that when I become a practicing media specialist that I do not shut myself off from implementing new technologies that may benefit the teachers and students in my building. I am so hungry for the knowledge that I doubt that will happen.
When I first started reading the articles posted for this blog, although this is a school library media program, I was thinking solely of the benefits of teachers using a wiki. Then, as I dove a little deeper, and especially as I read your post, I saw the immense opportunities and benefits for media specialists as well.
ReplyDeleteI think that the concerns that you pointed out, for both teachers and for media specialists, are quite valid. Time is the ultimate concern for anything “extra” as an educator, because our time is so limited and so precious. But, like you said, you’ll make time and you’ll put time in for something that you think matters in order to make it successful. If a teacher (or media specialist) is willing to take the time, maybe on the weekend, during planning, over the summer, whatever, to create and maintain a wiki for the students, I think that the students will greatly benefit from the advantages of a wiki. The students will have a place where their ideas are readily heard and valued, a place where they can receive additional information, and a place where they can communicate with other minds about their topic of study.
As a media specialist, I think a wiki is a GREAT resource for maintaining a webpage for the media center. I noticed as I was browsing the AHS wiki that it seemed a little old, so when you mentioned that it was the doing of the previous media specialist and that the new one has decided not to continue with it, it made a lot more sense. You are absolutely right that a wiki will begin to “collect dust” if the creator (and contributors) do not actively maintain the site. A wiki for the media center would be an excellent place for teachers to get the word out about events, students to learn information, and media specialists to post about resources in the media center. The idea of a team being dedicated to maintain the wiki is one that I hadn’t thought of, but an excellent use of collaboration. Share the burden and ensure that the site will be continued even if a teacher (or two or three) move schools – it’s a win-win.
I share in your hope that a wiki is something I can incorporate in my own media center, fingers crossed the teachers and students react well to it!
I love that you remind us not to create a wiki just to have a wiki. This is so true with all new tools and technology. I think that many of us have been asked to implement a technique or use a new tool when it didn’t quite fit the situation. When this happens a lot of time and energy is spent on something that is rarely, if ever, actually used. On the other hand if, as you pointed out, the implementation of a wiki is well thought out then it could be incredibly useful. I work in an elementary school, but I know that my personal children would have loved using a wiki when they were working on group projects in high school instead of emailing a document back and forth.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of specializing a wiki for the media center is a great one. We have talked for several years about different ways to encourage our students to recommend books to each other. Having one place where students could go to read reviews, get book suggestions and request new book purchases and then in turn leave their own input would be amazing. This is definitely something that I will discuss with my media specialist. Hopefully, we can design something that will engage our students in dialog about books and keep them coming back for more!
I like that your blog focused on the integration of the Wikis in the classroom. Wikis are all new to me, until we completed this assignment I was only aware of Wikipedia. I agree that they are a great idea but when you have standardized testing over classroom teachers heads it is difficult for them to put energy into something such as Wikis. I have only taught in an elementary school so I am not sure how it would work at the high school level, but it would be a great idea to have students run a grade level Wiki for the upper grade levels. I know that at my school we choose students for safety patrol and for morning announcements. An elementary media specialist could possibly have a select group of students that update the Wiki pages.
ReplyDeleteJohn,
ReplyDeleteI like how your post is setup. Very easy to read and follow. Your right, teachers need time to set up a Wiki...who has lots of that! But if it's high on the priority list. you will make the time. I do not see it as a top priority in my first grade classroom; however, I do see it being valuable maybe in our media center. I like how parents, students, and co-workers can contribute their thoughts on the site. Like someone else stated, a select few students could be encharge of updating the Wiki. The media specialist would need help and input from others. If that was going to happen, it may be beneficial.